Categories: Manifesto

Manifesto Score Case Study: Fail Bigger Cheaper

Our fourth Case Study using the Manifesto Score… How does a manifesto that is only three words long perform under the Manifesto Score?

Manifesto: Fail Bigger Cheaper: A Three Word Manifesto.

Created by: Umair Haque

Source: http://blogs.hbr.org/haque/2011/03/fail_bigger_cheaper_a_three_wo.html

The Manifesto

Fail Bigger Cheaper

Manifesto Score

YES Manifestos are primal: Umair is calling it a manifesto so he scores a point for that.

NO Manifestos terminate the past: Nothing ‘ending’ here.

NO Manifestos create new worlds: No ‘new world’ being created.

NO Manifestos trigger communities: No ‘community’ here.

NO Manifestos define us: No ‘us’ here.

NO Manifestos antagonise others: No ‘other’ here.

NO Manifestos inspire being: No ‘way of being’ mentioned.

YES Manifestos provoke action: I’m being generous here… This manifesto does call forth a solitary and single action.

NO Manifestos crave presence: As the author says, ‘Try this thought experiment’. How about if you’re serious Umair that you create a campaign out of this! Do you believe in your idea or not?

Score: 2 out of 9

Suggestions

Just putting the word ‘manifesto’ on the end of a statement does this proud and potent word a disservice. Some more work on all other 7 principles is needed here. In particular, this could be a great campaign if the author was serious about his idea.

Or perhaps, the problem is the title, the heading ‘A Three Word Manifesto’ is really a lie!

And probably a deliberate one to catch our attention. This is disappointing because the article is worth a read and this really could be a killer manifesto if taken seriously. Perhaps I should rewrite it for the author?

What do you think? Is that score about right? Or am I being overly sensitive?

Geoff McDonald

Share
Published by
Geoff McDonald

Recent Posts

Seven Ways to Create Your Unique Manifesto Design

How can you create your own unique manifesto design to bring your dreams and vision…

2 weeks ago

Unlock Success: 6 Types Business Manifestos You Must Know

Are you struggling with direction and clarity in your business? Without this, it’s easy to…

2 months ago

Four Best Ways to Write a Powerful Design Manifesto

What’s the best way to write a design manifesto? Previously, I shared four types of…

2 months ago

Best Life! How To Master The Art Of Intentional Living

Is the art of Intentional Living the secret to your best life? And how can…

3 months ago

Best You – How to Stick to Your Values – 28-Day Challenge

Can you stick to your values for 28 days? I took on a core values…

3 months ago

Your Personal Core Values – From Good to Great

Knowing your Personal Core Values is good. But how do you turn your Core Values…

4 months ago